By Dan Rubinstein
Photos by Chris Roussakis
Last winter, Carleton Indigenous and Canadian Studies Prof. Kahente Horn-Miller attended a symposium in downtown Ottawa on Indigenous knowledge and the education system hosted by the Pearson Centre for Progressive Policy.
At the time, she was developing an online class — Introduction to Indigenous Studies — and was exploring how to make online learning a useful tool for bringing Indigenous knowledge into the classroom.
Senator Murray Sinclair, the former chair of Canada’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), was at the symposium. One of the TRC’s Calls to Action is about integrating Indigenous knowledge and teaching methods into the country’s post-secondary institutions, and Horn-Miller was thinking about the most effective way to do this at Carleton.
Some universities have introduced mandatory courses for all first-year students. Others are opting for massive open online courses (MOOCs).
But there can be resentment when students are required to take a class, and it can be difficult to find enough qualified instructors to teach thousands of students. Moreover, it can be challenging to engage students in large lecture halls or through MOOCs, especially if they’re not invested in learning the material.
Horn-Miller had an idea: a series of focused Indigenous knowledge modules, available online for faculty members to deliver in their classes. But she didn’t like the term “modules.” Instead, the word “bundles” came to mind.
“Bundles are what we keep all of our teachings and sacred medicines in,” Horn-Miller says of the Carleton University Collaborative Indigenous Learning Bundles (CUCILB) project, designed as a resource for instructors and a learning tool for students to provide the factual and theoretical basis for understanding Indigenous history and politics in Canada, while prompting students to consider how this knowledge might be applied in their areas of study.
“Whether symbolic or real, we put our knowledge into bundles so we can share. ‘Collaborative’ is a key word too. We’re all doing our part, on either the process or the content, and building bridges while working together to make change,” says Horn-Miller.
“In our view — the Haudenosaunee view — when you come into this world you have gifts. When you grow up, you contribute to the collective by sharing these gifts. My goal is to connect with people and share. My role, as an Indigenous educator, is to provide opportunities for people to learn.”
Indigenous Learning Bundles Already Available for Classroom Use
The bundles were to be officially launched at an event at Carleton’s Ojikwanong Centre on Dec. 3, 2018, but four were already available for classroom use:
- The First Peoples: A Brief Overview
- Decolonization is for Everyone: Identity Formation in the Canadian Context
- Engaging with Indigenous Communities
- Indigenous Environmental Relations
Another four are in development, and Horn-Miller and her colleagues in Teaching and Learning Services (TLS), with help from a master’s student Courtney Vaughan, have roughly 15 more in mind, depending on funding and how people respond to the bundles.
TLS staff members — in the above photo, from left to right: Daphne Uras (standing), Renata Chiaradia (sitting), Elspeth McCulloch (standing) and Allie Davidson (sitting) — played a key support role in executing Horn-Miller’s vision. They helped organize, develop and structure the learning materials into the bundles from a pedagogical perspective, working closely with Indigenous experts to ensure that Indigenous ways of knowing were respected and implemented.
The topics are meant to span the university and fit a range of courses without being overly specific.
In the overview bundle, for example, the learning objectives include appropriate terminology for describing Indigenous peoples of North America, identifying and correcting common myths about Indigenous peoples, a basic definition of colonization and its impact on Indigenous peoples in Canada, and identifying major issues that concern Indigenous peoples in Canada.
Instructors can only use two bundles per course, and they are not permitted to slice and dice or unbundle the material.
Model is Attracting Attention Outside of Carleton
While created for Carleton, this model is attracting attention off campus, says Horn-Miller, who has shared information with the Ottawa Carleton District School Board.
The bundles are built around videos, slides, quizzes, discussion points and further reading, with expertise provided by scholars from Carleton and other universities (including Anishinaabeg Ryerson Sociology Prof. Damien Lee) and from knowledge keepers in Indigenous communities such as Stephen Augustine, Albert Dumont, Tony Belcourt, Katsi Cook and Tekwatonti Amelia McGregor.
More Interesting Reads
- Honouring Indigenous Heritage at Convocation
- Understanding Indigenous Land Claims
- Fish Research Links to Indigenous Heritage
Whenever Horn-Miller has invited somebody to participate, they have agreed. “They see the value of what we’re doing,” she says.
On the CUCILB web page and within the bundles themselves, a beaded “dish with one spoon” wampum belt is used a symbol of the project. This speaks to the idea of the “common pot” — the idea that we all eat out of the same dish with one spoon, ensuring that the dish is never empty as long as we embrace our responsibility of safeguarding the land and treating one another, and all living things, with equity and respect.
Traditionally, when Indigenous peoples travelled, explains Horn-Miller, they would request permission to use the natural resources in another group’s territory while passing through.
“It’s about sharing resources because we all eat out of the same pot,” she says.
“We’re sharing the resource of knowledge we have through this project to help bring people together. Because nobody is going anywhere, we have to learn how to get along. We have to learn how to talk to each other. We have to learn how to respect the natural world, so we protect her and don’t abuse her.
Hopefully, we can help shift perspectives around the idea of sharing and move away from extreme individualism. We can all benefit from the natural world if we all look out for her.”
Helping Students See the Importance of Indigenous Issues
Carleton Film Studies Prof. Laura Horak is one of the first faculty members to use the bundles in class, incorporating “The First Peoples: A Brief Overview” into her course on Analyzing Cinema, Gender and Sexuality.
Because part of the course investigates the ways that feminist, Indigenous, transgender and queer filmmakers have inventively rethought cinema and video for poetic and political ends, the bundle was a “perfect way to provide more depth,” says Horak.
“Having the voice of Indigenous scholars and elders as authorities on the political issues and lessons of colonialism really gave the topic more resonance,” she says. “It helped students see how alive and important these issues are.
“Indigenous knowledge and teachings are not something we can cover on the side just so we can check off a box. The knowledge of Indigenous scholars and artists is an essential part of this course.”
Familiarizing Students with Indigenous Knowledge and History
Horak, who plans to use the bundles again in her classes, discovered that some students were not as familiar with recent Indigenous history and political struggles as she had thought.
“They were amazed they hadn’t heard some of this information before and wanted to know more,” she says. “As a settler scholar, I can now present this information in more depth without pretending to have expertise that I don’t have.
“We went through the videos in the bundle together and then talked about it afterwards. Film and video are extremely powerful mediums. This is a wonderful resource.”
Carleton’s Indigenous faculty members are frequently asked to serve as guest speakers in classes by professors who want to cover Indigenous content in a respectful way. That can be tiring for professors who have their own courses to teach, research to conduct and students to supervise.
This has happened to Horn-Miller a few times already this semester. Now, she can point her colleagues to the bundles.
In addition to “bundles,” the Mohawk word tsinitsiwen’a has been top of mind for Horn-Miller while working on this project.
Although often used to connote “history,” it actually means “to make it alive in the minds of the people.”
“And that,” says Horn-Miller, “is exactly what we’re trying to do here.”
Ottawa Holocaust Survivors Tell Their Stories
Kati Morrison was four years old when her grandmother pulled her and her year-old sister into the dimness of a stairwell and saved their lives. The three waited silently while the other 100 or so... More
Carleton Congratulates Vanier Winners
The Vanier Canada Graduate Scholarship isn’t just prestigious: it comes with $50,000 a year for three years of a doctorate degree. This year Carleton congratulates four doctoral students — a new record — whose research... More
12th National Title
A welcoming committee of red and black swarmed Alumni Hall on March 21 as the Carleton Ravens brought home a sixth consecutive national win from the CIS men's basketball championship in Vancouver. The Ravens triumphed... More